TCLA Vacation Scheme Applications Discussion Thread 2024-25

Andrei Radu

Legendary Member
Staff member
Future Trainee
Gold Member
Premium Member
Sep 9, 2024
709
1,290
does anyone know what the longest time firms take post AC to respond to you if you got an offer is? I had an AC on Monday last week, so it's been almost two weeks and still haven't heard back. Is this likely a rejection because I see people usually getting offers the day after their AC or do firms still send out acceptances even two weeks later?
When I interviewed with Slaughter and May it took them around a month to get back to me and I ended up receiving a VS offer. With Milbank, I only heard back two weeks afterwards and also got an offer. While some firms will respond very quickly, others spread out ACs over a longer period of time and/or simply have more drawn out decision-making processes. As such, there is not much you can infer from the wait time. I know how difficult it is, but try to get your mind off what the outcome will be. I found it useful to channel the post-AC anxiety into applications-related efforts; as that kind of work made me feel like at least I was doing all I could to prepare for the worst case scenario.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Masharah

SoonToBeTrainee

Legendary Member
  • Dec 29, 2023
    141
    334
    Does anyone know what Kirkland and Skadden's policy on reapplying post video interview and interview respectively are?

    Thanks
    Many US firms like Kirkland and Weil don’t re-interview. They don’t advertise this, but I’ve spoken to senior partners at the firms who confirm that this in the case. It would make it a lot easier if they were transparent about it…

    I’m not sure on Skadden though, as I personally have no experience with the firm.

    I do partly understand why some firms don’t re-interview, but it is incredibly frustrating! People change! Also, it’s crazy to me that someone can have a bad day on a single AC, feel unwell, or just be unlucky, and then that firm will purposely never interview you again. It just doesn’t even seem logical.

    Our chances become slimmer and slimmer each year 😢
     
    Last edited:

    SoonToBeTrainee

    Legendary Member
  • Dec 29, 2023
    141
    334
    Is this rule the case even if someone had EC/MC on the day of their AC?

    I don’t really understand the reasoning behind it either tbh.
    A lot of firms do also re-interview. It’s kinda on a firm-by-firm basis as to who re-interviews or not though.

    Generally, I’d say it’s more likely that a US would not re-interview than a UK firm
     
    • ℹ️
    Reactions: Chris Brown

    ysr567

    Well-Known Member
    Oct 4, 2024
    22
    41
    Out of curiosity, how many work experiences should we be listing. I did a lot of extra curriculars inside and outside of uni that amounts to around 15 from sixth form up until now. I have a feeling that this is in a way holding me back and getting me the PFOs. Should I be including all of them or limit them to what I mention in my application form plus a couple extra relevant ones.
     

    Thom&as

    Active Member
    Feb 27, 2024
    17
    35
    It's a bit of a late update as I found out exactly two weeks ago, but I got an offer for the HSF Spring VS!

    Following a string of rejections last year where I had just fallen short at the final stages, I had doubts about whether I was good enough for commercial law. Reflecting on these experiences, I can say for sure that perseverance pays off.

    It might seem unfair, but luck definitely plays a part in whether you succeed. Whether it's in the form of a news article you stumbled across, or an area of law you explored in depth at uni, what's important is that you put in the effort to take advantage of the moments where luck is in your favour, and that you keep putting in the effort with the faith and confidence that your time to shine will come.

    Although I might not be the most active on this platform, a lot of the materials and discussions here have helped tremendously. Thank you to everyone for fostering such a supportive environment, and good luck to everyone yet to receive their offer!
     

    Ricky

    Legendary Member
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    2020 Community Winner
    Sep 16, 2018
    381
    1,650
    Many US firms like Kirkland and Weil don’t re-interview. They don’t advertise this, but I’ve spoken to senior partners at the firms who confirm that this in the case. It would make it a lot easier if they were transparent about it…

    I’m not sure on Skadden though, as I personally have no experience with the firm.

    I do partly understand why some firms don’t re-interview, but it is incredibly frustrating! People change! Also, it’s crazy to me that someone can have a bad day on a single AC, feel unwell, or just be unlucky, and then that firm will purposely never interview you again. It just doesn’t even seem logical.

    Our chances become slimmer and slimmer each year 😢
    I previously interviewed at Weil in 2021. I got through to video interview again this cycle.
     

    SoonToBeTrainee

    Legendary Member
  • Dec 29, 2023
    141
    334
    I previously interviewed at Weil in 2021. I got through to video interview again this cycle.
    They continue to put people through the process, but then won’t progress to AC.

    Perhaps there’s a very very slim chance that they change their mind or you slip through the net. But, I’ve spoken to the partners in charge of recruitment at these firms, and unfortunately they are very clear that they do not re-interview
     
    Last edited:

    Legalstalker

    Legendary Member
    Premium Member
  • Oct 9, 2023
    465
    1,981
    I suppose so. I was thinking about last minute things like maybe falling ill the day of the AC or something. Would a firm be able to reschedule at short notice? Sometimes they have limited AC days.
    I guess it depends if there are dates available after the original one and the type of illness.

    common cold/flu may impact the way you sound in your interview but the content shouldn’t be as you’d have prepared prior to becoming sick. Sore throat may affect participation in group exercises so that’s very understandable. migraines/headaches etc is down to the individual to decide how severe they are. Only illness I'd personally reschedule an AC for is period cramps. You’d never catch me at an AC with that. I’ve done video interview whilst being bed bound, tests after throwing up etc 😂 I guess it depends on how much you want it…​
     
    • ℹ️
    Reactions: Chris Brown

    James Wakefield

    Legendary Member
    Premium Member
    Oct 7, 2024
    278
    723
    They continue to put people through the process, but then won’t progress to AC.

    Perhaps there’s a very very slim chance they change the mind. But, I’ve spoken to the partners in charge of recruitment at these firms, and they are very clear that they do not re-interview
    From their perspective, it does make some sense. They can only invite so many to AC and all of the candidates they are considering at that stage will be strong on paper. One of the distinguishing factors they’ll have is whether someone was rejected after interview before and that’s an easy (but arguably lazy) factor to narrow down the list.

    I think firms which take a “never reinterview’ mindset will potentially miss out on good lawyers. Reapplying is a good indication of resilience, which is a characteristic they’re actually looking for!
     

    About Us

    The Corporate Law Academy (TCLA) was founded in 2018 because we wanted to improve the legal journey. We wanted more transparency and better training. We wanted to form a community of aspiring lawyers who care about becoming the best version of themselves.

    Newsletter

    Discover the most relevant business news, access our law firm analysis, and receive our best advice for aspiring lawyers.