• How confident are you in your knowledge of the core LLB/PGDL subjects, including Contract, Tort, Trusts, Land, Criminal, and Public Law?

    TCLA is teaming up with BPP for a free interactive event designed to refresh your fundamentals, especially for those interested in or planning to take the SQE. We'll practise multiple choice SQE questions, with prizes for the highest scoring participants!

    Register Here
  • Are you a future trainee?

    We're hiring at TCLA. Apply by midnight on 31 March 2025.

    Apply Now

TCLA Vacation Scheme Applications Discussion Thread 2024-25

Andrei Radu

Legendary Member
Staff member
Future Trainee
Gold Member
Premium Member
Sep 9, 2024
678
1,240
Does grad recruitment tend to take in overall appearance during VI's? Like if the content of my answers are good but I stumble over my words once or twice, or have to take a second to continue?
I think recruiters focus the most on ascertaining whether you have sensible substantive points and on whether you can communicate them properly. As such, the way you go about articulating your thoughts does play a factor, but as long as your points are good and overall clearly expressed it's not a major consideration. Stumbling once or twice is definitely not a big deal, it is a lot more common than you think. I progressed in VIs in which I struggled significantly more in terms showcasing clear and composed communication.
 

Andrei Radu

Legendary Member
Staff member
Future Trainee
Gold Member
Premium Member
Sep 9, 2024
678
1,240
Yeah, GD only recruits through vac schemes. I'm just really nervous tbh, i know they test more commercial awareness and general abilities but then also some of the questions on glassdoor are stressing me out. Someone said they got asked "what makes GD different to Cleary and Linklaters?" Is this likely to be cos that applicant said they also applied to those firms, or just randomly? Because I could answer that compared to other firms i applied to but definitely not with random ones. Does anyone have advice?
While I do not know the context in which this question was asked, I would say based on my own interview experience that it wouldn't be impossible to be asked something like this even if you have not applied to these other firm. The interviewer may want to test your ability to think on the spot about comparisons and issues you may not have considered before and also to test your broader knowledge of the legal market in London.

To answer it, firstly you definitely want to know what are the main firm 'types' - ie Magic Circle/SC/etc but also large/mid/small offices of US firms and also further differentiations between any big practice area/sector focuses - ie 'transactional' and 'disputes' firms. While you need not have a lot of specific knowledge about any of the firms within the broader groups, you need to know the main features associated with these categories. Thus, even if you do not know much about Linklaters, you should be able to different it from GD merely by knowing what makes a firm 'Magic Circle': long history at the pinnacle of the legal market in England and deep ties with UK corporates; top of the market strengths across the spectrum of a full service offering; an expanded network of international offices; a structured training style; large trainee cohorts etc. The same points of differentiation will appear if the interviewer asks about Clifford Chance, Freshfields or A&O Shearman.

Secondly, you need to know the unique selling points of GD and its practice area strengths, and you need to know what other firms those unique selling points/practice area strengths also apply to. If you have found a specific enough conjunction of why GD reasons, there should be no other firm they equally apply to and thus you should always have at least one point of differentiation - with Cleary, maybe the firms have in common strengths in cross-border disputes and mid-sized London offices; but Clearly does not have GD's market recognition for corporate M&A.
 

Andrei Radu

Legendary Member
Staff member
Future Trainee
Gold Member
Premium Member
Sep 9, 2024
678
1,240
Does anybody have insight into whether Davis Polk is highly selective when it comes to academic grades, meaning that successful applicants are likely to have at least a first-class degree or a strong 2.1?
The firm indicated that they expect successful candidates to be on track for/have achieved a high 2.1, but that they will take into account mitigating circumstances and that therefore this is not an absolute requirement.
 

AnAnonymousDuck

Valued Member
Sep 21, 2024
100
77
While I do not know the context in which this question was asked, I would say based on my own interview experience that it wouldn't be impossible to be asked something like this even if you have not applied to these other firm. The interviewer may want to test your ability to think on the spot about comparisons and issues you may not have considered before and also to test your broader knowledge of the legal market in London.

To answer it, firstly you definitely want to know what are the main firm 'types' - ie Magic Circle/SC/etc but also large/mid/small offices of US firms and also further differentiations between any big practice area/sector focuses - ie 'transactional' and 'disputes' firms. While you need not have a lot of specific knowledge about any of the firms within the broader groups, you need to know the main features associated with these categories. Thus, even if you do not know much about Linklaters, you should be able to different it from GD merely by knowing what makes a firm 'Magic Circle': long history at the pinnacle of the legal market in England and deep ties with UK corporates; top of the market strengths across the spectrum of a full service offering; an expanded network of international offices; a structured training style; large trainee cohorts etc. The same points of differentiation will appear if the interviewer asks about Clifford Chance, Freshfields or A&O Shearman.

Secondly, you need to know the unique selling points of GD and its practice area strengths, and you need to know what other firms those unique selling points/practice area strengths also apply to. If you have found a specific enough conjunction of why GD reasons, there should be no other firm they equally apply to and thus you should always have at least one point of differentiation - with Cleary, maybe the firms have in common strengths in cross-border disputes and mid-sized London offices; but Clearly does not have GD's market recognition for corporate M&A.
This might sound like a really silly question, but if I was asked about a firm that i had never heard of in my life and didn't know anything about, what would be the best response? Would asking for more info from the interview be an absolute no-no or is it just best to admit defeat and say "I don't know that firm"?
 

theone132213

Well-Known Member
Feb 23, 2024
20
8
Does anyone have tips for answering an app question on setbacks and overcoming them?
I’m struggling to identify what they mean exactly by a setback- would a challenging scenario suffice, or do you have to have failed? This is for Ashurst if that helps.

Any help much appreciated :)
 

theone132213

Well-Known Member
Feb 23, 2024
20
8
Does anyone have insight into whether Pinset Masons prefer bullet points or prose for their work experience section? Also any insights on their online assessment? Thank you
I think I remember them saying prose is fine. As for the test, it entails an SJT + Verbal + Numerical test followed by a written task and then a VI. The written task and VI will only be looked at if you pass their benchmark on the initial test ( but you complete them all back to back).
 

-legal-

Esteemed Member
Premium Member
Jul 5, 2023
77
79
Hi @Amma Usman @Jessica Booker ,
Would this section also include positions of responsibility and if it doesn't is it fine if I only add my non academic interests as I can't think of anything else.

Please use this section to tell us anything else that you feel would support your application. Examples can include, but are not limited to, key achievements, successes, non academic interests, your skills etc.
Max 300 words
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amma Usman

addy2004

Legendary Member
Premium Member
  • Nov 28, 2023
    126
    239
    Does anyone have tips for answering an app question on setbacks and overcoming them?
    I’m struggling to identify what they mean exactly by a setback- would a challenging scenario suffice, or do you have to have failed? This is for Ashurst if that helps.

    Any help much appreciated :)
    From my experience, the setback needs to be an actual 'setback' (so more of a 'failure'), and then you can explain what steps you took to overcome it and what you have learned etc. This shows more growth, development and awareness in yourself, rather than using an example of a setback that isn't really as serious/many people have encountered (eg rejections). What I'm trying to say is don't be afraid to use a more personal example to write a compelling answer - how you explain your growth is what matters.
     

    Jessica Booker

    Legendary Member
    TCLA Moderator
    Gold Member
    Graduate Recruitment
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Aug 1, 2019
    15,299
    21,356
    Hi @Amma Usman @Jessica Booker ,
    Would this section also include positions of responsibility and if it doesn't is it fine if I only add my non academic interests as I can't think of anything else.

    Please use this section to tell us anything else that you feel would support your application. Examples can include, but are not limited to, key achievements, successes, non academic interests, your skills etc.
    Max 300 words
    Yes - you can include positions of responsibility within this question unless there is a separate question/section asking specifically for this evidence.
     

    About Us

    The Corporate Law Academy (TCLA) was founded in 2018 because we wanted to improve the legal journey. We wanted more transparency and better training. We wanted to form a community of aspiring lawyers who care about becoming the best version of themselves.

    Newsletter

    Discover the most relevant business news, access our law firm analysis, and receive our best advice for aspiring lawyers.