TCLA Vacation Scheme Applications Discussion Thread 2021-22 (#1)

Status
Not open for further replies.

AP2000

Distinguished Member
  • Feb 22, 2021
    55
    91
    So I took part in an inter-university commercial awareness competition recently. We were in small teams, and my teammate and I had to present back to the panel on a case study. Our presentation had multiple sections which we split amongst ourselves. They start first, I go next- all good so far. When the last section comes about they go way over the time limit of 1 min (which they had told me to strictly stick to in the preparation breakout room) and I am left with less than 30 seconds for my last section. I can only outline what I was going to talk about in a sentence before being cut off. Then there are questions from the panel- and I don't get to say a single word. They take up all the questions, including the questions regarding my part of the presentation. I unmuted myself multiple times but they took up the question nonetheless and as soon as they were done the panel member asking would say thank you and move on.

    I am not shy or introverted. I am a confident speaker who has presented in high profile conferences and forums. I am also the "mother" of the group in group projects, always making sure people contribute and that work is allocated fairly- I don't try to make myself stand out over the rest of my team.

    This experience made me feel so defeated, patronised, and small. The only positive part of it is that the outcome (which we found out in a few days) is assessed on a team level, and I must have done something right because I've had legal recruiters of the sponsoring firms reach out via LinkedIn.

    Beside the rant, I guess the question here is: have you ever had to deal with difficult and "macho" team members like that, and how did you cope?
     

    Jessica Booker

    Legendary Member
    TCLA Moderator
    Gold Member
    Graduate Recruitment
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Aug 1, 2019
    14,663
    20,356
    So I took part in an inter-university commercial awareness competition recently. We were in small teams, and my teammate and I had to present back to the panel on a case study. Our presentation had multiple sections which we split amongst ourselves. They start first, I go next- all good so far. When the last section comes about they go way over the time limit of 1 min (which they had told me to strictly stick to in the preparation breakout room) and I am left with less than 30 seconds for my last section. I can only outline what I was going to talk about in a sentence before being cut off. Then there are questions from the panel- and I don't get to say a single word. They take up all the questions, including the questions regarding my part of the presentation. I unmuted myself multiple times but they took up the question nonetheless and as soon as they were done the panel member asking would say thank you and move on.

    I am not shy or introverted. I am a confident speaker who has presented in high profile conferences and forums. I am also the "mother" of the group in group projects, always making sure people contribute and that work is allocated fairly- I don't try to make myself stand out over the rest of my team.

    This experience made me feel so defeated, patronised, and small. The only positive part of it is that the outcome (which we found out in a few days) is assessed on a team level, and I must have done something right because I've had legal recruiters of the sponsoring firms reach out via LinkedIn.

    Beside the rant, I guess the question here is: have you ever had to deal with difficult and "macho" team members like that, and how did you cope?
    Your team mate would have been scored down for that behaviour. Hopefully the feedback will make them realise this isn’t how to work in teams.
     
    • Love
    Reactions: AP2000

    George Maxwell

    Administrator
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Junior Lawyer 50
    Oct 25, 2021
    551
    1,085
    Thank you so much, I will definitely take you guys up on that offer!! Is there anything I should currently be doing specifically, besides keeping commercially aware etc. (VS is in June and I’m a non law student). Many thanks again everyone!!
    Hey @Salin,

    So my advice is to remain familiar with your CV and application answers that you submitted to the firm when you applied. My supervisors were sent these ahead of me arriving and asked me about them when I started.

    In addition to the above, I would take a look at the practice areas that you are due to sit in (if you have been told). I found it helpful to have an idea of the major clients and notable matters that the firm had been involved in the couple of years prior to me starting too (particularly those that included the practice area I was sitting in). This knowledge helps to contextualise a lot of what is said in meetings which makes them easier to follow. Being proactive about finding out about the firm's work will also reflect well on you too.

    The last thing I would say is to think about the sort of work, clients and practice areas that genuinely interest you. For example, before my scheme at HSF I did a vacation scheme at Akin Gump, where I sat in financial restructuring. I really liked it so I wanted to learn about the sort of work that HSF does in this area, which led me to having coffee with a few people.

    If you are able to say at the start of your scheme, "I am particularly interested in X":
    1. Your supervisor and buddy might be able to put you in touch with another lawyer who has direct experience of X; and
    2. You might be given work/opportunities relating to X (which will make your VS engaging which will likely mean you do even better than otherwise!).

    This post repeats some of the above, but might put things slightly differently too :).

    I hope that helps and is clear!
    So I took part in an inter-university commercial awareness competition recently. We were in small teams, and my teammate and I had to present back to the panel on a case study. Our presentation had multiple sections which we split amongst ourselves. They start first, I go next- all good so far. When the last section comes about they go way over the time limit of 1 min (which they had told me to strictly stick to in the preparation breakout room) and I am left with less than 30 seconds for my last section. I can only outline what I was going to talk about in a sentence before being cut off. Then there are questions from the panel- and I don't get to say a single word. They take up all the questions, including the questions regarding my part of the presentation. I unmuted myself multiple times but they took up the question nonetheless and as soon as they were done the panel member asking would say thank you and move on.

    I am not shy or introverted. I am a confident speaker who has presented in high profile conferences and forums. I am also the "mother" of the group in group projects, always making sure people contribute and that work is allocated fairly- I don't try to make myself stand out over the rest of my team.

    This experience made me feel so defeated, patronised, and small. The only positive part of it is that the outcome (which we found out in a few days) is assessed on a team level, and I must have done something right because I've had legal recruiters of the sponsoring firms reach out via LinkedIn.

    Beside the rant, I guess the question here is: have you ever had to deal with difficult and "macho" team members like that, and how did you cope?
    Hey @AP2000,

    I am really sorry to hear that you had this experience. It sounds like it was hugely frustrating. You do sound like you dealt with it in a professional and mature way though, which is impressive. It is not easy to work with someone like that and not allow your emotions to get the better of you.

    Based on what you have said, I really don't think you should feel small or defeated. I think you dealt with an irritating and difficult situation well and you should feel proud of yourself that you were able to remain civil and calm (at least ostensibly) in a stressful situation.

    I actually had a very similar experience. I actually discussed my discomfort with my partner as soon as I was able to. I mentioned that I felt uncomfortable with the way that the situation had been handled and that I would have appreciated it had they had worked with me during the assessment. This made no difference at the time as the assessment was over, but I did find it therapeutic to voice my frustrations with them. I came away feeling more sensitive to the feelings of others in groups - which ultimately is a really important insight to have. So although the competition did not go your way this time, I bet you will be a better trainee in the future having had this experience, as you will know how important it is to communicate well with those around you(!).

    It also sounds like your maturity and capability did shine through given that some legal recruiters have subsequently reached out to you!
     

    James Carrabino

    Legendary Member
    Future Trainee
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Junior Lawyer 11
    Oct 12, 2021
    666
    1,558
    Wanted to give a shoutout to @James Carrabino and @AvniD for doing a really great webinar. \Really great advice and really inspiring to hear about the direct TC route I never thought the direct TC route was as easy as you made it as most people go down the VS route.

    Also well done on doing the webinar as it must have been hard for both of you and being nervous doing a webinar and you lot did a good job please can you both do another webinar together but maybe on assessment centres as your advice was so helpful and so inspiring.
    Ah thank you so much @Asil Ahmad, this really means a huge amount! It was wonderful to be able to present our thoughts to all of you :) I think that Avni and I could be convinced by lovely feedback like this to do another one in the not-too-distant future, now that we got the initial nerves out of the way 😊
     
    • Love
    Reactions: Asil Ahmad

    Asil Ahmad

    Legendary Member
    Premium Member
    Forum Winner
  • Mar 29, 2020
    1,640
    2,160
    29
    Ah thank you so much @Asil Ahmad, this really means a huge amount! It was wonderful to be able to present our thoughts to all of you :) I think that Avni and I could be convinced by lovely feedback like this to do another one in the not-too-distant future, now that we got the initial nerves out of the way 😊
    Look forward to it and you both should be proud of yourselves as it is not easy doing a webinar to a lot of people.

    I also think doing a webinar about case study assessment centres will be a good idea for the future.

    Also, thank you very much once again for the great webinar and good luck to both of you on your upcoming exams.
     

    James Carrabino

    Legendary Member
    Future Trainee
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Junior Lawyer 11
    Oct 12, 2021
    666
    1,558
    Look forward to it and you both should be proud of yourselves as it is not easy doing a webinar to a lot of people.

    I also think doing a webinar about case study assessment centres will be a good idea for the future.

    Also, thank you very much once again for the great webinar and good luck to both of you on your upcoming exams.
    Thanks so much once again - and the luck will be much needed on the exams!

    @AvniD let's keep a webinar on case studies at ACs in the back of our minds :cool:
     

    s10

    Distinguished Member
    Oct 1, 2020
    60
    431
    So I took part in an inter-university commercial awareness competition recently. We were in small teams, and my teammate and I had to present back to the panel on a case study. Our presentation had multiple sections which we split amongst ourselves. They start first, I go next- all good so far. When the last section comes about they go way over the time limit of 1 min (which they had told me to strictly stick to in the preparation breakout room) and I am left with less than 30 seconds for my last section. I can only outline what I was going to talk about in a sentence before being cut off. Then there are questions from the panel- and I don't get to say a single word. They take up all the questions, including the questions regarding my part of the presentation. I unmuted myself multiple times but they took up the question nonetheless and as soon as they were done the panel member asking would say thank you and move on.

    I am not shy or introverted. I am a confident speaker who has presented in high profile conferences and forums. I am also the "mother" of the group in group projects, always making sure people contribute and that work is allocated fairly- I don't try to make myself stand out over the rest of my team.

    This experience made me feel so defeated, patronised, and small. The only positive part of it is that the outcome (which we found out in a few days) is assessed on a team level, and I must have done something right because I've had legal recruiters of the sponsoring firms reach out via LinkedIn.

    Beside the rant, I guess the question here is: have you ever had to deal with difficult and "macho" team members like that, and how did you cope?
    It will be super helpful to remember that while this type of behaviour might have made them feel and seem capable in the short run, this behaviour is hardly rewarded in a professional setting. These competitions arent just an opportunity to fill out your resume, but very substantive opportunities to develop your transferrable and professional skills. So I guess one silver lining you can take away is that you have learned what to expect from some types of people and maybe even diffuse those type of situations. P.S - the next time grad rec asks you "tell us about a time you worked with a difficult reason" at least you have a very valid and pertinent example to work with 😅
     

    James Carrabino

    Legendary Member
    Future Trainee
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Junior Lawyer 11
    Oct 12, 2021
    666
    1,558
    View attachment 4013

    Can somebody clarify what this means? Can I apply for White & Case's direct TC after being rejected for their VS a couple months ago? (i.e., applying for the TC in the same cycle after being rejected from the VS).
    I would e-mail them to clarify, as the wording here is a bit unclear and last year they definitely allowed candidates to apply for a direct TC in the same recruitment cycle that they were unsuccessful for VS. They only did not allow candidates to reapply who had reached the interview stage.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: djqb

    letmeintolaw

    Distinguished Member
    Nov 11, 2021
    59
    161
    I am making one of my final applications however on the date that the interviews would be held if my application were to get through, I will be doing a vacation scheme. Is there any way around this? Should I email the firm and explain before sending my application or will the dates be non-negotiable
     

    George Maxwell

    Administrator
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Junior Lawyer 50
    Oct 25, 2021
    551
    1,085
    My biggest takeway

    The main takeaways were that they explained the difference in the level of commercial awareness required for interviews at direct TC application than at VS interview.

    Another takeaway that I was shocked about was the thing about work experience and that someone with no legal work experience got a TC through the direct TC route. Also, the session was really informal and interactive which I loved.
    Thank you for sharing this @Asil Ahmad! I will be looking out for the recording when it is released 💪
    Had a feedback call after an unsuccessful post-AC. However, I found the feedback to be super encouraging. The interviewers said I was more than capable of doing the role and that I showed a strong understanding of the firm and showed enthusiasm for embarking on a career in law. It was my first ever interview so I am really proud of myself, although it's not the outcome I wanted, the feedback has made me want to try even harder! :)
    Hey @Nicole15,

    What a fantastic attitude to have! It sounds like you smashed your first interview and it is credit to you that you are focusing on the positives in a situation like this. Awesome stuff 🚀
     

    Jessica Booker

    Legendary Member
    TCLA Moderator
    Gold Member
    Graduate Recruitment
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Aug 1, 2019
    14,663
    20,356
    I am making one of my final applications however on the date that the interviews would be held if my application were to get through, I will be doing a vacation scheme. Is there any way around this? Should I email the firm and explain before sending my application or will the dates be non-negotiable
    I’d wait until you know whether you are selected for interview or not, and then see if the firm has flexibility. Your vacation scheme firm may also be more flexible than you think and may be able to give you a couple of hours/half day off to attend an interview (this is actually quite common, and as long as you make the time up for the rest of the week, it typically is not an issue unless you have an assessment with the VS firm at the same time).
     
    • Like
    Reactions: letmeintolaw

    S87

    Legendary Member
    Gold Member
    Premium Member
    Sep 4, 2018
    1,648
    2,403
    Hi @Jessica Booker,
    I am getting in touch with a number of firms to explain my mitigating circumstances and how they impacted on my grades. Because I want a direct answer how can I be bold without sounding rude?
    thank you 🙏
     

    Jessica Booker

    Legendary Member
    TCLA Moderator
    Gold Member
    Graduate Recruitment
    Premium Member
    Forum Team
    Aug 1, 2019
    14,663
    20,356
    when you do group exercises, what are the first words usually spoken? Do people assign roles to themselves like PM/note taker/time keeper or just get straight into discussing the task without worrying about formal titles?
    Don’t try to over think/formulate it - flexing and adapting to the group/exercise rather than setting an expected agenda/discussion is important.

    If roles are needed though it is important to define them early and make sure everyone is clear on who is doing what.

    My advice is to try and forgot it is assessed and think more about how you would approach this task if it was real work.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    About Us

    The Corporate Law Academy (TCLA) was founded in 2018 because we wanted to improve the legal journey. We wanted more transparency and better training. We wanted to form a community of aspiring lawyers who care about becoming the best version of themselves.

    Newsletter

    Discover the most relevant business news, access our law firm analysis, and receive our best advice for aspiring lawyers.